"The maintenance on the southern front during the Yom Kippur war" (Hebrew) paper, written by an IDF ordnance officer for command and staff course in 1990, is available on the IDF ordnance corps association website. Part 9 of it includes details from the damaged tanks survey the IDF had carried out after the war, on pages 293-304.
According to the paper, 214 damaged tanks were examined: 114 Shot Cal, 51 Shot Meteor, 35 Magach 3, 17 Magach 6. These numbers add up to 217. No Shermans or Tirans mentioned.
Expect for 20 (Magach) tanks examined on field, near the Chinese Farm, all the rest were examined in an ordnance depot in central Israel. 110 were from the Syrian front (66 Shot Cal, 44 Shot Meteor), 74 from the Egyptian front (51 Magach, 22 Shot Cal, 1 Shot Meteor), for 26 there was no record where were they evacuated from (Shot Cal tanks served on both fronts). Here the numbers add up to 210.
Number of hits per tank: 75% were hit once or twice. 25% took 3 hits or more. 1.9 hits average per tank. 2 tanks took as many as 7 hits. On the Syrian front: 35% were hit once, 39% twice, 2.1 hits average per tank. Egyptian front: 54% once, 26% twice, 1.8 hits average per tank.
Hit area: 35% turret front (30 degrees), 18% turret sides, 11% hull front, 36% hull sides. In another place, the report claims that 71% (=35%+36%) of the hits were in the turret, 29% (=18%+11%) in the hull. That's probably a mistake.
Hitting munition type:
Egyptian front: 16% RPG, 26% Sagger, 3% tank-fired HEAT, 9% other HEAT, 23% 100 mm AP, 23% other.
Syrian front: 7% RPG, 3% Sagger, 5% tank-fired HEAT, 6% other HEAT, 29% 100 mm AP, 19% 115 mm AP, 31% other.
HEAT munitions had the highest penetration rate, 86%. No significant difference between turret and hull penetration rates.
Total loss: 20% on the Egyptian front, 9% on the Syrian front.
Common damage to Shot tanks: 33% manual gun elevation mechanism, 28% TC's copula, 26% gun barrel, 24% radio, 24% gun mantlet dust cover, 22% manual turret traverse mechanism.
Common damage to Magach tanks: 37% gun barrel, 34% TC's copula, 23% radio, 17% TC's elevation and traverse mechanism, 17% gun mantlet dust cover, 15% loader's hatch.
http://www.himush.co.il/?item=198§ion=51
http://www.himush.co.il/himush.co.il/originals/ 9.pdf
http://www.steelbeasts.com/topic/11688- … nk-survey/
отсюда